[nakul]

Hi,
I have modifed the rhoCentralFOAM solver for viscous supersonic flows to incorporate combustion and mixing. This solver is capable of simulating supersonic combustion. The combustion code has been taken from reactingFOAM. I have named it "rhoCentralSpeciesFOAM".

I have done a test case simulation with this and it works. But there are still few issues with the solver. The solver is not very stable. It is still quite sensitive to test case setup. Although the solver works but the results are not very accurate with increase in the complexity of chemical reactions.

I request the OF community to have look at this solver. Any suggestions regarding any modifications are highly appreciated. Steps needed to integerate it with your OF have been specified in the following post.

-Nakul

[nakul]

1) OF-1.7x should be used because the thermodynamics is based upon sensible enthalpy. This change has been introduced in OF-1.7x only. Hence the solver won't work on any previous versions.

2) Firstly copy the rhoCentralFOAM solver from "$OpenFOAM/applications/" folder to some other location within the OF folder,

3) Delete the "Make" folder and all other header and C- files that are there. Don't delete the BCs folder.

4) Copy the files from this solver into your folder and rename the folder to "rhoCentralSpeciesFoam".

5) Run the wmake command and the solver would compile. If you face any errors, just let me know.

-Nakul

[arvind_arya]

Hi Nakul,

Can you post the case you have simulated.!!!!!

Thanks

[JLight]

Hi Nakul
Have worked on something similar with sonicFoam ... if anyone is interested I will upload it. Still in the process of validating the results.

As Arvind indicated it will be great if you can post your results so I can compare it with mine.

Cheers!
J

[arvind_arya]

Hi Nishit,
I would like to have a look on your solver as well as your case file.....Kindly upload them.!!

[Lella]

Have you validated it?

[JosueMG]

Hi JLight,
I would be interested in giving a try at your solver - sonicFoam + chemistry
can you upload it? have you validated it yet? I want to simulate detonations with detailed chemistry

[Iain_symthe]

Originally Posted by nakul

Hi,
I have modifed the rhoCentralFOAM solver for viscous supersonic flows to incorporate combustion and mixing. This solver is capable of simulating supersonic combustion. The combustion code has been taken from reactingFOAM. I have named it "rhoCentralSpeciesFOAM".

I have done a test case simulation with this and it works. But there are still few issues with the solver. The solver is not very stable. It is still quite sensitive to test case setup. Although the solver works but the results are not very accurate with increase in the complexity of chemical reactions.

I request the OF community to have look at this solver. Any suggestions regarding any modifications are highly appreciated. Steps needed to integerate it with your OF have been specified in the following post.

-Nakul

Nakul:
When I tried to compile your solver with OF 1.7, I get an error. See attached output of ./Allwmake
Could you please let me know what I am doing wrong?

thanks

[reza_65]

Originally Posted by Iain_symthe

Nakul:
When I tried to compile your solver with OF 1.7, I get an error. See attached output of ./Allwmake
Could you please let me know what I am doing wrong?

thanks

I think you should follow these steps:
1- first check whether did you include the BCs folder from rhoCentralFoam solver?
if not include that folder in it.
2- if you have done that part, you need to be sure that you have compiled OF 1.7.1 very well in your Linux, and for this reason just try to re-compile one of the existing solver and just rename it, to see whether you do not have gcc problem, cause OF 1.7.1 use gcc 4.4 however in the latest version of Linux, you might have gcc 4.7 or 4.8 or above.
if it's the case try to use wiki website for re-compiling your OF 1.7.1

At the end, I would tell you that I tested this solver many times ago, and it has got some issues. but you can work on it to improve it. otherwise, I suggest you start from scratch and get one of the latest version of OF, and try to combine (rhoCentralFoam + reactingFoam), (which I myself have done it for my PhD).


Regards,
Reza

[skumar112]

Could you send me the combustion solver you have created for sonicFoam to skumar3344@gmail.com

Regards
Sunil

[Iain_symthe]

Originally Posted by reza_65

I think you should follow these steps:
1- first check whether did you include the BCs folder from rhoCentralFoam solver?
if not include that folder in it.
2- if you have done that part, you need to be sure that you have compiled OF 1.7.1 very well in your Linux, and for this reason just try to re-compile one of the existing solver and just rename it, to see whether you do not have gcc problem, cause OF 1.7.1 use gcc 4.4 however in the latest version of Linux, you might have gcc 4.7 or 4.8 or above.
if it's the case try to use wiki website for re-compiling your OF 1.7.1

At the end, I would tell you that I tested this solver many times ago, and it has got some issues. but you can work on it to improve it. otherwise, I suggest you start from scratch and get one of the latest version of OF, and try to combine (rhoCentralFoam + reactingFoam), (which I myself have done it for my PhD).


Regards,
Reza

Thanks, Reza. Could you please send me a tarfile of your solver to symthe_Iain@yahoo.com? If you could also include validation cases and the set-up that would be great

[pattim]

Have there been any successful cases of supersonic chemistry using these solvers (sonic solvers modified to include chemistry)? If so, can these be made available online or else sent email to me? miche1@earthlink.net I'm new to OF and would appreciate any simple cases examples. Thank You!

[hyFoam]

Hi Pattim,


Please have a look here:
https://github.com/vincentcasseau/hyStrath

Thanks,
Vincent

[Tobi]

I move that thread into the community contribution section

[ghazal_1989]

Originally Posted by hyFoam

Hi Pattim,


Please have a look here:
https://github.com/vincentcasseau/hyStrath

Thanks,
Vincent

Hi Vincent,



I tried to compile the solvers of hyFoam and hy2Foam on the OpenFoam-V6 and got the following error. I was wondering if you could tell me whether these solvers can only be compiled on the OpenFOAM-V1.7x?


Best,
Ghazal


/usr/bin/ld: cannot find -lstrathReactionThermophysicalModels
/usr/bin/ld: cannot find -lstrathSpecie
collect2: error: ld returned 1 exit status
/opt/openfoam6/wmake/makefiles/general:167: recipe for target '/home/ghazal/OpenFOAM/root-6/platforms/linux64GccDPInt32Opt/lib/libhyTwoFoam.so' failed
make: *** [/home/ghazal/OpenFOAM/root-6/platforms/linux64GccDPInt32Opt/lib/libhyTwoFoam.so] Error 1

[Daniel_Khazaei]

Originally Posted by ghazal_1989

Hi Vincent,

I tried to compile the solvers of hyFoam and hy2Foam on the OpenFoam-V6 and got the following error. I was wondering if you could tell me whether these solvers can only be compiled on the OpenFOAM-V1.7x?

Best,
Ghazal

/usr/bin/ld: cannot find -lstrathReactionThermophysicalModels
/usr/bin/ld: cannot find -lstrathSpecie
collect2: error: ld returned 1 exit status
/opt/openfoam6/wmake/makefiles/general:167: recipe for target '/home/ghazal/OpenFOAM/root-6/platforms/linux64GccDPInt32Opt/lib/libhyTwoFoam.so' failed
make: *** [/home/ghazal/OpenFOAM/root-6/platforms/linux64GccDPInt32Opt/lib/libhyTwoFoam.so] Error 1

Hi,

These errors you have posted don't reveal the exact cause of the compilation failure.
It can only be understood that none of the two necessary libraries have been compiled correctly and consequently the main lib itself failed due to the missing libraries.
The real error is way above this line and sending the complete log probably helps identifying the problem.

[hyFoam]

Hi,


The correct OF version is OF-v1706 for the Master branch, that is ESI branch of OpenFOAM(.com).
Please read the step by step Installation guidelines in the hyStrath/Wiki



Thanks

[ghazal_1989]

Originally Posted by hyFoam

Hi,


The correct OF version is OF-v1706 for the Master branch, that is ESI branch of OpenFOAM(.com).
Please read the step by step Installation guidelines in the hyStrath/Wiki



Thanks

Hi Vince,
Many thanks for your reply. Unfortunately, I was unable to install OF-V1706 on my linux 16.04 LTS. I could only find the installation's comments for the OpenFoam-V1812. I would appreciate if could help me on this.

Best, Ghazal

[hyFoam]

Hi,


Source files - please pick v1706:

https://www.openfoam.com/download/release-history.php


System requirements:

https://www.openfoam.com/documentati...quirements.php


If that's what you've done, please give more details as to what is not working. Also, this might not be the right thread to talk about installation issues given an Ubuntu version.



Thanks,
Vincent

[ghazal_1989]

Originally Posted by hyFoam

Hi,


Source files - please pick v1706:

https://www.openfoam.com/download/release-history.php


System requirements:

https://www.openfoam.com/documentati...quirements.php


If that's what you've done, please give more details as to what is not working. Also, this might not be the right thread to talk about installation issues given an Ubuntu version.



Thanks,
Vincent

Hi,

Thank you so much. I've finally installed OF-v1706 sucessfully and also compile hyStrath-master on my system. However, hyFoam CFD solver (supersonic combusting flows) has not been compiled and only hy2Foam and hy2MhdFoam solver can be used. I would appreciate if you could help me on this.


Best,

Ghazaleh