Fluent Non-Positive Volume

eishinsnsayshin · April 6, 2012, 14:18

I'm trying to run a Fluent simulation and am having some trouble getting my solution to stop diverging. I created my 3D mesh entirely using ANSA13.2.1 (both surface and volume). When I do a mesh check in ANSA, there are no intersections, the skewness is below 0.8, there are no duplicate nodes, and it finds no negative volumes. I import my .msh file into Fluent 13.0 and there are no errors. When I run my model I get an epsilon divergence about 200 iterations into solving. I know the parameters/boundary conditions are set correctly because I have a very similar model meshed with tetras (instead of hexas as in this model) that I use a journal file to read in the bc's.

The only thing in fluent that hints at the source of the problem is if I do a mesh check. It says "warning: non-positive volumes exist", and lists the minimum volume at about -2.03e-03 (m^3). It also finds about 15 left handed faces. Perhaps I have a problem with my mesh. In ANSA, I can't find any issues though (as I described above). For the left handed faces, I use the orient tool in ANSA to ensure all my normals are pointed in the right direction, so I'm not sure where it's getting left handed faces...Does anyone know if there is a way for fluent to spit out coordinates of problematic areas so I can go look up that region in ANSA? My model is pretty large (60 million cells) so if there was some way to pin point a problematic region, it would be great.

I'd really appreciate any advise!

vangelis · April 9, 2012, 08:21

Hi there.
In ANSA v13.2.x you can check for left-handed elements if you activate this criterion in F11 Solids tab.

Does your model consist only of trias and tetras, or do you have other elements as well?

Also I would like to ask if it is a matter of precision.
ANSA v13.2. is double precision. If you have a great spread of length scales in your mesh, you could try to staet Fluent in double precision mode and read and check the mesh again.

April 6, 2012, 14:18	Fluent Non-Positive Volume	#1
eishinsnsayshin Member Join Date: Jun 2011 Posts: 48 Rep Power: 15	I'm trying to run a Fluent simulation and am having some trouble getting my solution to stop diverging. I created my 3D mesh entirely using ANSA13.2.1 (both surface and volume). When I do a mesh check in ANSA, there are no intersections, the skewness is below 0.8, there are no duplicate nodes, and it finds no negative volumes. I import my .msh file into Fluent 13.0 and there are no errors. When I run my model I get an epsilon divergence about 200 iterations into solving. I know the parameters/boundary conditions are set correctly because I have a very similar model meshed with tetras (instead of hexas as in this model) that I use a journal file to read in the bc's. The only thing in fluent that hints at the source of the problem is if I do a mesh check. It says "warning: non-positive volumes exist", and lists the minimum volume at about -2.03e-03 (m^3). It also finds about 15 left handed faces. Perhaps I have a problem with my mesh. In ANSA, I can't find any issues though (as I described above). For the left handed faces, I use the orient tool in ANSA to ensure all my normals are pointed in the right direction, so I'm not sure where it's getting left handed faces...Does anyone know if there is a way for fluent to spit out coordinates of problematic areas so I can go look up that region in ANSA? My model is pretty large (60 million cells) so if there was some way to pin point a problematic region, it would be great. I'd really appreciate any advise!

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
mesh missing after import in fluent	morteza08	FLUENT	0	July 23, 2010 03:22
[blockMesh] BlockMesh FOAM warning	gaottino	OpenFOAM Meshing & Mesh Conversion	7	July 19, 2010 15:11
Volume mesh for Fluent.. Hypermesh or TGrid??	mayur	FLUENT	5	June 25, 2010 02:45
virtual volume in Fluent	kartik	FLUENT	5	October 10, 2008 08:11
How Does Fluent Handle Volume Flow in 2D and 3D	Shawn	FLUENT	4	July 16, 2008 15:38

April 9, 2012, 08:21		#2
vangelis Senior Member Vangelis Skaperdas Join Date: Mar 2009 Location: Thessaloniki, Greece Posts: 287 Rep Power: 21	Hi there. In ANSA v13.2.x you can check for left-handed elements if you activate this criterion in F11 Solids tab. Does your model consist only of trias and tetras, or do you have other elements as well? Also I would like to ask if it is a matter of precision. ANSA v13.2. is double precision. If you have a great spread of length scales in your mesh, you could try to staet Fluent in double precision mode and read and check the mesh again.